Looking for a quote?

At Hutsenpiller Insurance, we let you shop for insurance the way you want.

Choose what works best for you:

  • Submit your information securely online and we’ll take it from there

  • Schedule a call with a licensed Hutsenpiller agent if you want guidance

  • Get a quote online on your time, without pressure

Whether you want to click, call, or just explore your options, our job is to make sure you’re properly covered and actually understand what you’re buying.

Submit Info
Schedule Call
Online Quote
sales team newpng
heartemoji
Personalized Solutions

Get coverage tailored to your needs.  Every client is different—we take the time to understand your situation and find the best fit from top-rated carriers.
mindblown
Expert Guidance

Our agents know the local market and provide clear advice, so you never have to guess about your coverage.
flex emoji
Claims Advocacy

We’re with you when it matters most. If you ever have a claim, our team walks you through every step, making sure you get the support you deserve
party emoji
Community Focused

Trusted in Middle Tennessee for over 30 years. As a local, independent agency, we’re committed to our community—because we live here, too.
Learn More About Us

What do we cover? Pretty much Everything.

We’re not just here for your car or your house—we’ve got your whole world covered. From the essentials like auto, home, and life insurance, to the fun stuff and investments—think watercraft, travel trailers, ATVs, business coverage, and investment properties. Whatever you care about, we know how to protect it. 

Don't see what you are looking for? We can probably help. Reach out to one of our team and we'll be happy to assist you.
Auto Insurance

Protection that moves with you. Stay on the road with coverage that actually fits your driving life.
Home Insurance

Safeguard your sanctuary. We protect your house, your stuff, and your peace of mind.
Life Insurance

Because your family’s future matters. Coverage that takes care of them, even when you can’t.
Business Insurance

Built for local business owners. Shield your livelihood from life’s “what-ifs.”
Boat Insurance

Make waves, not worries. Coverage for your boat, jet ski, or anything that floats.
Camper Insurance

Hit the open road with confidence. Protect your home away from home, wherever adventure calls.
ATV Insurance

Take the trail, not the risk. Coverage for your four-wheeler, side-by-side, or off-road toys.
Investment Properties

Grow your portfolio, not your headaches. Keep your rentals and real estate assets protected.
Learn More About Us

Meet your new agents

cj Hutsenpiller
CJ Hutsenpiller
Agency Owner
Shea Hutsenpiller

Shea Hutsenpiller
Director of Compensation

Tanner Sandel
Tanner Sandel
Director of Client Experience 

 

Jessica Davidson
Jessica Davidson
Insurance Agent
Madi McNesse
Madison McNeese
Insurance Agent
Caetie Page
Caetie Page
Insurance Agent
Eric Henry
Eric Henry
Insurance Agent
tylerallen

Tyler Allen
Insurance Agent

Camilo Arango
Camilo Arango
Insurance Agent
4b0643_ca324afff9374bc6bbaf8418e082b29c~mv2
Kenzie Hammock
Insurance Agent
Rebekah Wallace
Rebekah Wallace
Commercial Lines Team Lead
Marie Freels
Marie Freels
Client Experience Team - Agent
Jordan Kilgore
Jordan Kilgore
Client Experience Team - Agent
Cindy Moses
Cindy Moses
Client Experience Team
Ciarra Ballinger
Ciarra Ballinger
Client Experience Team
Megan Brothers
Megan Brothers
Client Experience Team
5f3e14_833c663521af48b3a819978f73c480ab~mv2
Edwin Orozco
Client Experience Team 
Jayvee Teczon
Jayzee Teczon
Sales Team Assistant

 

Want to learn more about insurance? (exciting, right?🙄)

Check out our recent blog posts
3 min read
What to Do After a Water Loss: A Step-by-Step Insurance Guide

Jan 22, 2026

A water loss can happen fast. A burst pipe, leaking appliance, roof leak, or storm-related water intrusion can quickly...
3 min read
The Deductible Strategy Most Homeowners Don’t Know About

Jan 20, 2026

If your home insurance premium has gone up over the past few years, you’re not imagining it. One of the biggest drivers...
3 min read
High Wind & Hail Deductibles: How Tennessee Homeowners Can Lower Their Risk and Save Money

Dec 15, 2025

The Rising “Storm Tax” on Your Roof If you’re a homeowner in Tennessee, there’s a good chance your insurance policy...

Why choose us?

We've been protecting Tennesseans for over 30 years.

caricon
0 +
Vehicles Insured
houseemojiii
0 +
Homes Insured
money
$ 0
Premium Saved Clients
tristarr
0
Years in Business
irwin

Emma D.


Lebanon, TN

"CJ & his team have been great to work with! I'm a new client and they have been very attentive and quick to respond with any questions! Plus, I'm saving money and getting extra bonuses to my coverage than before!"

John Griffin

John G.


Mt. Juliet, TN

"Good people. Good location. Honest & reliable. Family/Locally owned. Customers come first with this group. Love that they shop rates for me. One of the best in Middle Tennessee!"

rick blair

Rick B.


Mt. Juliet, TN

"I have been a customer of Hutsenpiller Insurance for almost a decade now. CJ & the staff are personable, professional, and extremely efficient. "

Get a quote