High-Tech Coverage. Hometown Service.

Local expertise, multiple carriers, and an agent who actually picks up the phone.

At Hutsenpiller Insurance, we are a local, family-owned, independent insurance agency that blends the expertise of local insurance agents with cutting-edge technology to deliver an effortless, stress-free insurance experience to our clients. From personalized guidance to seamless processes, we're here to make every step simple and convenient for you.

Get a Quote

How can we help?

Complete this form to be contacted by our team.

A legacy of family and community

Proudly serving Mt. Juliet, Lebanon & Wilson County since 1992.

At Hutsenpiller Insurance, we're more than just a business, we're a family, and we're your neighbors. For generations, we've been part of the Mt. Juliet and Lebanon communities, building our agency on the values that matter most: trust, integrity, and a genuine dedication to the people of Wilson County.

From the moment you reach out to us, we aim to provide a personalized experience that feels less like "just insurance" and more like being cared for by someone who truly has your back. Whether you're a homeowner in Lebanon, a small business owner in Mt. Juliet, or raising a family anywhere in Middle Tennessee, we treat your coverage with the same care and attention we'd give our own.

Your satisfaction isn't just a goal, it's our legacy. We've worked hard to create a company where every customer feels like part of our family, and after more than 30 years of serving this community, we wouldn't have it any other way.

Insurance Agents in Mt. Juliet and Lebanon

Get a quote

Looking for a new quote or just want to see what options you have? This is the place to start.

Get Started

Customer Service

Need help with an existing policy? Our team is ready to assist with anything you need.

Service Account

Claims

Need assistance with a new or existing loss? Our team is ready to help with expert advice.

File a Claim

Personalized Solutions

No cookie-cutter policies here. We dig into your specific situation, compare options across top-rated carriers, and find coverage that actually fits your life, not just a generic quote.

Expert Guidance

Insurance shouldn't feel like guesswork. Our agents know the Mt. Juliet and Lebanon markets inside and out, and we'll walk you through every detail in plain English so you always know exactly what you're getting.

Claims Advocacy

When something goes wrong, you shouldn't have to fight your insurance company alone. We go to bat for you, guiding you through every step of the claims process and making sure you get what you're owed.

Community Focused

We started right here in Mt. Juliet, and after 30 years we've grown to serve families and businesses across the state. But no matter how much we grow, one thing stays the same — when you call us, you get a real person who actually knows your name.

What do we cover? Pretty much Everything.

Your life doesn't fit in a neat little box, and your insurance shouldn't either. We cover the essentials: auto, home, and life - but we also protect the stuff that makes life fun: your boat on Old Hickory Lake, your side-by-side, your camper for fall weekends. Plus business coverage and investment properties for when you're building something bigger. If it matters to you, we know how to protect it.

Auto Insurance

Protection that moves with you. Stay on the road with coverage that actually fits your driving life.

Home Insurance

Safeguard your sanctuary. We protect your house, your stuff, and your peace of mind.

Life Insurance

Because your family’s future matters. Coverage that takes care of them, even when you can’t.

Business Insurance

Built for local business owners. Shield your livelihood from life’s “what-ifs.”

Boat Insurance

Make waves, not worries. Coverage for your boat, jet ski, or anything that floats.

Camper Insurance

Hit the open road with confidence. Protect your home away from home, wherever adventure calls.

ATV Insurance

Take the trail, not the risk. Coverage for your four-wheeler, side-by-side, or off-road toys.

Investment Properties

Grow your portfolio, not your headaches. Keep your rentals and real estate assets protected.

Got questions? We've got answers.

We know insurance can feel overwhelming; there's a lot of fine print and not enough plain English. Here are answers to some of the most common questions we hear from folks across Mt. Juliet, Lebanon, and Wilson County.

I had been with Liberty Mutual for many years. I called Hutsenpiller and Caetie Page gave me quotes on home, auto, and boat. She saved me a ton of money. I love having a local voice to talk to rather than a call center.

Ed Coffman

Homeowner, Lebanon, TN

★★★★★

CJ and the team make insurance easy! We had a homeowner’s claim in March, and they went above and beyond every step of the way

Jonathan Drake

Homeowner, Mt. Juliet, TN

★★★★★

I had been with AAA for 20 years and they were trying to raise us over $600 per year. Jessica came to me as a referral and I chose her because of how quickly she got back to me. She found me incredible rates with the same coverage and is saving us hundreds and hundreds. So glad we found her!

Nicole Anderson

Homeowner, Lebanon, TN

★★★★★

CJ and crew take care of all our insurance needs for our home, auto and businesses. Their customer service exceptional. CJ has called us on more than one occasion to tell us that he is going to make some insurance changes that are going to get us better coverage for less money! They are a staple in our MJ community and are constantly promoting small-local businesses.

Dr. Liz Totty

Homeowner, Mt. Juliet, TN

★★★★★

Marie Freels from Hutsenpiller Insurance helped me make a seamless transition to some very cost-effective auto/home insurance companies. We did everything online, and the process was easy. Marie was also very knowledgeable & answered any concerning questions I had. Thank you!

Bethanne Weatherford

Property Owner, Wilson County, TN

★★★★★

Hutsenpiller Insurance truly goes above and beyond. I worked with Madi and she answered all my questions, provided clear guidance, and made the entire process smooth from start to finish. Exceptional customer service—would absolutely recommend for homeowners and landlord insurance.